%PDF-1.5
%
4 0 obj
<>
stream
ABBYY FineReader 152023-05-24T15:31:23+03:00
Отзыв оппонента на диссертацию
endstream
endobj
7 0 obj
<>
stream
x+T034R0 A#9@HLBPP(U!\!"
R
h046wwwW0 N
\.
\=61d~K>W "
endstream
endobj
8 0 obj
119
endobj
9 0 obj
<>/Length 63377/Type/XObject>>
stream
} :]SI2R@pG,y6BM^?K4qYN^?-1Zњ-rD (AN(
P\B8$">Ô8luGLH0XHl[!0 l, qz
@ÄMkzm)cߖ>Xx.8"=^Kl]Yc(yc>ר]厥K&X0T>P ?DQ(yP⤃> #ж(8qRǴGHCAX2#&9>c>*a!;WcXo&=:\WlycaJx9cce,u,|o,|U!*=c>,{,,}!eBLunfRҖ>1Kuv!ka4J!A(bAAeK_#PeB2(2+B(r(tr8
"""""""""""#u}MXC;J?̊xɵu[ܘ[Z)rsŖx kpdpS9(rPcЈaPim(Mߠ
wm%7i|Kq.aPȃC1Ѹ#yD|#hdtaP莈ԈG*XMFEh`DaN'28!@uDtG莏gȎ3ΑhtN& P aS ahDDXB"Y dAr)]EkdtalGH#:#1?G$Db:.Ch0h"٦ $O9C'aNa&8aH6 M@؈ahZa$k74289#dtGdtGDw#ѼlQ"F{?DtOFhD$GFq1m#ČڻoNvAt0,ɐi)c9CxD蛔8`A"p
9CAi"8""."""",!
0
qB" Ѝ^u&&}
oAsQ lH`09CrNq0!9Cp QncM0 AF;dQ2UK][j}M֭ZMMwI[vC[B!km#
;A44#3ij~k_IzMi?kat:KIރPokAϽ-kMﷷ76뤒OMheoP&+⣶~i7Mۤ[{ut^J+_v_j_~j'{`_!wjKIaگݯ~봖I/R躳JwW$plLQqP}UUQuUҽ{t^ioP ~I".6%#?_K}kT,B(+OuUK_J$D4LuDzA$#|a'GIh\&GbKID?!Mqa"?UDOJFbA,w"r+WMu]~!l]iH4.9O1R] U)f$uuZU~.hi>"N";4hWVkxArS^]HwHBm{ޞ_t^7u:_afH.
wνoIw6Vna~AWvkz{7u%]i$a/ti~~u{m-?Zޒ껿,u^__Ui.)Ӵm~ޛM^>]:MOi~ק^{K
_U%]ii}zޗ~tKu:{nk턘h4;.莓MXmw#I=l0>npLݿVuo%vW[եMxbDqA0A"" څaa 6 &J#iZa#GiY0Wn$OKovLSP莧Bl&A":L&00Baa040I:#a U FXjlT0LIa]n\DDDDDDDC(B""tlʰA,r&;Dl(a6ApɈX"1!M0BbL&Zh4Ӈ@Ӳ
IdtG=Ga""" 0B YVӔ9VPeT0L8">R(r=Jc;eb A%AL aAI
#b r""""""""+aeQ(! 9NPԡ(r 9C#SeT&PAC(rGA96PaL36@3CsVqeSC9C9C,pDy4PDDD3u* !ՄױqiDDA`M}Z؋pB ePPk(r(p"##>GwȌɷ:#B
gk pr:"Io&9NSC:kB-bh]両 ^ 'tA?ǯI6IiӾݷORqko
o-DK(7D=8EÓNdr6莈GDtG3n!L &;A Cئ"6"-j29dtG#9:#tH"
GfSdU6fPyD]}TyD|4Z. "U
ӿNmWBNM4@ݠ00[Th0L&Qh4!N3
0#A"
b
X!0@A< d,C1gLA
l'
P !]fC_J
%uյJiAa^h4""`l vL)'(vaapaA&E,raa0&8oH32 C-(v
uah
ͅa'״nSMIf":Mގ9C}V#ƴq꺥zv[_'MRc-OWAuT_DiqI'G#-v/}
ZƗ_58l!m_z9
8":{FK|V|DE.n"Z:azһKO
#28&4;.華 _Py_kK}.W(sX&K5]
ʲ
~*O
r0UB=-qIAzӠI. mEhDDV-BKB"""+Dഢ"#zov'J֩Iܲ2>9C&]+Wi=IetܡaO}--9.[:ꝭ}tmI:{۾B?
WS
-7Ū_m-7$n)nR_IwTio&vJK&GeP=-]tNۤզAjZJպkOm*[VK[I6ޖm{ Vw//
.[
+V-{-Im
I9n+ݭ'o }nV cj턛KJKKutOVTiW~U{mOKu_۶ΟU^ڥa(`0kjTVB]Tuq/I[IߤbIp<,&a-ӫ[vTZpoIKwkzUuTZi#ꩶ
M]m-ᄺꫥ&PuJK᮵,0h40Ej-;VW/#֭.g$һ=k_V]Zo
mu6J`_Am0"c=00tAaa
A+Omj
onV_ [بՊVa0`KoD*ʣeCh0*
t":ir)ɎqCGLÔ:9C=BPia>4mB8A0A40h;40mUiiIJNAbgv V!khDDTDDDDDDDDDDDDNA"H:e9NP3PdF;H0bjh[ L&PM 4bAGH0ah4LA8m4µh("9*iȚ8""$@"X e%B(r3PM˄
H4]ZV.& %iպ$0La5J"""""""." n,DDDD!hCDDpeA9NaAoDTDqe2(pDtG]o*\E7Wo$
-.{}RK}a&GIBM>Y|(pE)ʅC:.<7KQd;"#fŐ`
BVYrjm촛1XH"(Lv4ldqLȎB%AACEHDR%0)"^b1Dt"CE3Hry1 m @atB
hņ!8p4aI4alAlBM6ACa 6ai'KlPW];K}^4a'II7N:ZW][[IVtGDm4]'U~oWZZm$$@g B\L(莈쎋G2tyF31Oޝmi==m i*`B"-Ў"YC@
'BGbt]tIz;EE;hz/PaC a%PM4vB"
f[ "ն'!}n#T}HhG{=
}w_zWM___hDbzPcT%ϒ_Ҡ}=z$9oMn[^ Er>IQpA3H#}^OUFW{i
K/u\?I~]{IW8Dǽi$^2>GDwA7=SX[[,RХ}j[{I6MpDw^B
}7}-{xoN҄ۺӾ.ҦѳzZ~;adtGԶߵwz3{;nBEkO5DAZD~IΪF
m#;1k9C8":
q:ޓ[ Alr>_KU_NDu."""]"6?Ӫnq>T]oWMM4eBKzIm~{Zmw;4_JUZ]K_붖 t$Z]7l%IնKzm}Ҥ.Jm&կo۪ҼwJҴGҶMmk;kNuk]7VznPRp҆aDt8am+5bdrMm[A]:ACI+&?M+!Aa Lpi a1JIXj%&mk6
u
=KҺtMv!iva `a&MVAl0Il0I;N%JK]]Um[UVA%I&`VP9NP2(rr({A9Caa0e$b
a
$&&A &aԎl$ #vxUV"80B!eaN3гT*!KBM1 sqB0`)A#L2(xB" 0 !0qVDDDDDDD2A`DQ`DYC莚!SpIiH- -z ðePPP(rA8P& & A|FDDDDcD18yi""""""""-0L!!P8":e9C#P#1oɱHDPB"*#Jz/kHIU_gTW;XT0A4ǥ=2*V\1zV&Jh |cзKA)Yo莈Dth$"6&0IndaBJ÷MHUݺ*^uդv=..WJ)t+Dr:#:0GG#}8T#EI~\
hDDE"І`Bl0lSX29:#:8!̣&3$G_kv'm` D0L&W@hAȕ4C$ ">Y!YgB;%Ea,Z2$GaRm A8fh4i
0B`@a"n"ca(MI#; ۸d2SC#!8R8
k"){,r8!8J9;Al9|XB C0PLPPh" _r/9>0XbW(GWW
m A}4AlHm aKx|dJ]
m( lECBb$9
!lSQ$aE@؊ TEEDP ІG@F2:?DtuUum.&[ڵpGzSSMvZ Z/d(r"9C㰋'(vnPEa0h4h"sl E
*/h0A4ElY5ݽ/^<'[I&mh#O]` ,vm"xvЈzmmH6i
Ӵjh Hm5W/T{v?z[g龕G`7mBn#3IUtޒIwnuUtH/MZMMt Zi'%V/zoI}vGWeG
zi$ح\9Ǥݶoo-[I[ۯW}ҿU_Wt]V!^0UX8/U_B/Dt{oZ_ItۯnU*MutX
+;m_$~եMy#UפkV]^JHtU2;#ڻwOGa->D&CP~~mЈQV+C>ч*r?^}-zds]oӡ{#I~赭(r#G]^ Nܱ9crWV@Z]ﴴ[sPu]4Dy~Tt?_ۂծ+=/_D{"c#8T""9i&GDtGDtַ Lza--%ЈsYCeSҽk}.MQܧ(rꉎP/\MDj[ӥ"wTDF]9V"/Wazlt[9C1ǶC70Ojh.[9(rn|DD^Ϋ.t}K_.}a
0B!-|DEeCp@iwK[}.^_٩_zo]}*zTڦOXI]UZ/o&zZ֓|BOb_Za_ߊ{ΩVշj]%Ϋ*Ҥm't &i}_gNUk}\[vu^=IlKoҭoJ[K֯My&NүK^ݭj+U:(VIaj[u3]nKnmiu
I_v!LRkWwt(0/=]$o}Xi/
]R֖^ݫi_ժ[iR__PAh" ViէlJa(Ոb$_]GA$Za%l#6l/0+a^څa~LBa! a AP#n\ZMVUm+WvW}WL0I.%C/ bӽ.K0E ^եh$E9C 5M46A
T0 n0@
0H! 87 GXM:Tݤ&U3m%V%8ڵb*'qzIh/4""""" B\*ppD|(@aKJH0Cl0ӒiBJa 4A PAizl0A i A6ipua-MeZ0eSq9C9(r 9Pq(r(rL(x`9Cq9C:Ii|4帄A0 a&i WmB&!&iaRiL0Aa+Ј"""""""""""؈b"""""4#0!ʂ(r(pD#PF]eSPZW#4G@r*#d$4ʂ2Ph":"PC@+L:`$K،!
""""""""""""""80@":rZ{UIDDDGZI*^"I$[ %ӕ%[i%r
ҫ6
ށMDFaDDDGX-D;Dti~ȳb؋P`Za5e6Pu"{NW2EIi*tԮ!B8@DJBPZ\YC
ƳUjBD*eejQIAr?VlDDP@؊8!YB!'EcGDx9 ш9͢r:!2:"HGaKKz/ܡ輆F9NP8A @(D(vAh0":aqlqPظf3a! 2(1&933sLÕeqE
$ABPVJq-*,9DrWK[1h%Ǫ֒}>iv%z.莈莋Iu'DGidp_KKPҧVJJNVޞ[ZmMoU#[UnTX=hVF}i=tCV߽WM^_KoաzZ_ڋ^Z}S>m}4q>,UTwkQ0!xx\O[
߶I:dC=u=iVaZ'$+J]Zh Ah-T}F!koӭ,Gߨ-th?$pEJKTV>9Cr8.N _ooZK.:]]j{*^e^ &%^*wJ`z[tGD""?ULw^]&G%`ִ#a/TY"EXit8K/Ahtu}.B@զ.'o6"=Ii#崞 ct_}& :]zWXAxKI{L&o]>Y}WAh%D$9C~iP[dvG?,v&iκWgU+i5֏
mS5nZe߄wМ&C_} pؖ:lwӴvu)WKn!}M
~jVZW[i-
PPPXRzKڰ1Ii[^H+]}bjΝ\zMu[ޭۚXO}kӪX鶖Un munⴚ~ۅ\jz;uM}*VU?=R^O-$KNtv{0K[Joҽ}VuVtI]Xn0_*m4a&nuK{i]ݻjꗰ[b4+.F&_K_}Ua(077in%4~5o#5:FTmi/ֶkvhdtAH4iCU54بbwP^ccNoa2ڰ-[
=/i6
&o{0v\50aL 6
0@ 'pNm;6'qOvi1z&G%V)SO_80JM%BCM=k(j$beMq2":e`":
":eS8"?(r89C1骄
i0`paM i T
lkL5'*`vIOؠXa+bhiFƝKqDӱ4`A8L&P9P(rr(tGV3PPaL9Ch0
; aL m,CEa4H0B`a#4 LB`Bl, 8i[lOTDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDYDBPPJ)#=t(60(&;PiAiOi&
LziMMTNt4"""""""""EDDDDDD2$Ӄ*U\:#&֮"""""""'Uw""Y5օWڼ.Ae2?YMf>s.GGG3h#b4"-гXr0enha4(i&0b_KUm-XY? V?qk
%6{Gxz_MºޖI%jq[\Uz餺ZRnuNצ__;M^ׄaAAI= &aAPA2Bh2r(pP(pDue ?Q2j?,8\ZnLDrOO3"ȡʼn\#"ٯ&`! ;#8b42D=b/(rzVN "դںA6XpVGA*jm*uor2VߥN!=WIA8ީwqr8s\
N!GE">Dg}ѩhH4.)"#F$9L\ÔUr(sy#O(D|2:54yDt}DtqDtt)E"_K/
0p1MhB.")@ Ih!hZqaN"()AGDx#"摈΄D/ѭ":!tGGyGmtdtAdz#yy": D]yQ
ˬ7Z]wNnMar.v8oIZ۬qA!6"š
РB $*,"ʸࠄCHC$pB5b|-H)^]+n^4ڤmR6&
ӴaL"W
8Eh
#r]a0E&a M|"c;nI[M0&--I߽Ut(uA+iNZHIn܄:Ai@vL*
|MfC
GWh4¶]KiU/uZMi]:z+I /inKWl9EX诪C"P_Fp?2:#[H/^[I-ՠnX0kZ"
T@] A
F-i%oK
]}% Vڵ-hrCB]/H.z(r)cv#i-֯x_im7iޯh*I.մES $]rW#M~߭%,q_z毷uih-=ޓ!{.q]+W!?}&ΞjZSBM}m*nKmAumuzK[
.Zm5^,}۽KRz_kiR{SMՋ֢nm(a/?kKOi:}MUOv_tWM+UIilo uIl,4tunIukZ7!;j5AWi; 'IQ(pUctwa 0+I
lvm?oIm<0i4!&lPjЅH"IU
M+ӽX6+T`vGUi'~RLw,pDx0aԡ#i a
叴 'uQ
0[&DC*JMh!
4tlTDDDqe)Zji{IuƿnM0
؊
:B (r(pEZaDDDxk(Yk`
TT D͋ aiHIjp!D
N莈K:#qDts92#gԎUC&9/D0d(v &` ☠Aad)|!,c9A>.SrsCrMD"" Ɖba0AaKA;
ac9"nH i,#4-0@"BA (CfBl!Ahu莏2:#DtO":#;D_V_UNۊ+o8!7I )oQU'vmW+BvM}t/Nˢ<6Zz8WoIV+ ҺNյw[_IWnk*7o"6]qQ]־oA.u6U%5c;q[_m+u9C8I/;~X[KViWu']R_J߿6뺥BiID|&(rʰ{Z{k
;I*vtqۿ^5+KM=v}DD~!_I-KGAS__I%t/]w_͈keF9Cz"P-vG@1z S@Zu {zP]aDwG*I/I&M!c;jȣ?A>MMЗ%+8(z28GDu߄Mv_nem ^i | ~XҤ"?c?@W;YNYۧ5y?m/.N;hKZmzzoeQN
9p{~Kqo;:o߯٩[PO Te]ۥ ^8}_[ڦ&_l}}ӻ~O!־]4.KV__+]pS[zIVVkM.ZMoMV_MvM7{K-۽*}&TZnս'[%WiJ%
&a&U-鮾{҅i[_
o֓ߧiFRO41)%]XUI^յo[֯noIv~V{_<0µe$av'qKQPX\.O^MџIXi%^a*o[[߿It߮ &!E`j7j+tմJ$k}CFMMR6Ji*M].i3qܘÂl h`a0C`1NM4OjQR-XaVӵm+Khئ_a38"""JH 0L,xa5
ia#AA
`*Ai5i14
6M;OL3bzq
:ハmt!DDDDDDBuHP0L&WԡrlRCQ1cS& 9cbG
iaL1Q A4il&
C#iLXADDDDDDDDDDDA0B&f.U#ʰXa0I4`aǼ0Â#$a+<5
0Ijq,R\Ia0 9N r(r=7EDDEDDD!SV"メDvKU5A{M(A`ÄNPTDDDYfn,u ZTaP!*T+F{(h\ xADaBB\9Ȏe̎JZ?4GE'07lMTLSZ0""P!#[t]
QD|z96s>萍B"
=
M //a A `00
aa#7$@-.Bel0rf)O2s#:#tGd<3">yD!c$4GDtqΨgC5dLh#L3A#'CGFv!wn&t iS h%0AP7N~ y[N
5L&І4*H"0L:'l&0np8l &; 4\N]v
h(v\0I:h&D[E1`Ao_M?IAIMӮ4кB7(uavmMB
64~ v mSHCmsq~mPaHXrikiM_+{jWX)=:'oIݪotptt[;Iu^l8D(vІm4KKkKm(OzM;Gu_]i6
nw[ۨJ!WxN}Mտt~ oלɺ飼)h\w|?1In NAm\"Gwݫ,v^AՑ_/]%WK
,0U&;o jPzK
KhA]7Zn=W_~Km;- zÿH%|7nA:i?սz6֓noI?t鴛AczZ3ooOm7~үUI_v)?K+mjV5'm*I~ΫTΫyծ}$uWtIT1ZWO~[ޞ}Si*Gm;jީ=nIzUեz^O{گwUV[a0"a.B_]핥[XV~᤻ޛzT]S/턘aIQN0Ҵ5V*m]S]Wu{]M6k^վn P t!tAD4i$mmmhÎU (VN%tm:U_+l0E֔0I[l#0{ͫJ3o#IW/Z
0
aRaA 9c
0iM&^JMPm(iq8$[KiXa;#IXV;nZmva"{X%TCC(rR"GD|.A(r#q#0Tbja a
P
A:cM4ӊca6T40q4(`bhIjݫiqC#&u'DG@(tGL(HLv<&J)n!
A0Alapj;
lBD mBMaTmP mC蠈`
0v""""""""""""*@¦(r(r0L'Lw&;&:#`C C
A˄9a0& uDu{A
6}8؈""""82K5"E2(pL(r 9(p}?"""""""""?o_tG#i?w&L@aA"d?YBA R&I0&n"o*ah+EMDeu fa\!(!dtal2GE0dtFyU:x
b$/=z] ߭I/SSUݻI݂0.\!% Շ^TRܡ9NP~_2 iAl=t zI}ݛ4b6X>c
^6D1R5V~I&oz}jݫ(9|@pKү=Ᏽ/-DaӶ!ɎePkP}%lz|&va/o呒zꗷOopgګ_KAzoO}&ԓ/[k^U}-7]^=
iwO{,rMI}&*juԗ#@vu^~TRTm\/7?OM[^%^z}JۧZ"Ҷv_ zZi{ҨKOi5ڿzӥ{6گSi{\VgNοSiqW[mlU[հ
%i]V_Wk^ױUM_]t$ilS[
_U:^nZt[_K %h/mk~ۭvثVZN8I.KӺ]6&XK$0AZm&
{aI&i1L0bKaK)/jnݢC aaMA
$A`l$LM4Va8/k:[DŽXT[KOKVӃ Pa
Ltg0AAA!0AÆ`#A:in*mQa$/M4iDtG@m""*""""""""" L9C#g(u(s(r,{ҰL&i6aHhaap8A
6
A
)GAh5; ! paA4
=4ЈC8A\Q!3Ч+epA9X+=8 `1C#<040j4ECTi႐p9binn
jML ۮ"""""ie"jB" S8"GDt:#wDDDDDG[Oɰ}
KJ~EJPcDD6o5)|DjZ
WM2>CkӰMb+b0))* 2R:#t]dGF|.hdYy8F8hGdLB Atd88Ј^kU{kDKT~7nm$gK\zO\9!nK8v`M.tZ^@ꗽ4{#:_zuEلDI3%W`Dt+P20K__!m%M /"!~'DD[h+];9OuvnZO-R_{I=M-{,r&XQNvG }M$>{{|mw_k]7zҺ"tK?BߠCm&iӖGWJI6dշ:gTCKsjMu_o}T/J$սnu]W~Eq_ZZV~_IԻIkv}wW'N]7i?߿SOWVE-J֟:&Κ[VZK:]OƖzOOkJvj}'jݿ*T$iiXJնtºVit[ zޚNuoii֞IU.WL%`WioZ_M6=(tᥪit 7'0`jQc[ثI#MZ]im-a}%a&[L0V+VJՈAM
Bnˢ:#m6PZv:kj |28>6* Lj-1tp
0@iM
DDX@
0aV M4ˠT:l ث*إjIlU¶ 5IZJD,uDtㅆa)1&!4T iA
' (vA4M0
P*A6*aA6$N
"""$u eHt-J}ئh4AAHhnA
RST viI zÈ$QlLʀDtXJʄePeS8 8AP0LC(s
GL:t a(pALpLѩ(p@@@8LGLpGAW]DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDG[U^sK^֩Vr$P%?4x' 9j'B9Cu$]ta̎6P)#=:8DgDDD\E8Lde莏:#:9DtyGF2"HKᄨaA#$B"""4"Z!KlYdtG)C#;?vqs9GeDB2]#GEr"#Qy3#_6m0 Mo
j
4pab$(aRQa ,[!]DC;!s4ϑN!!CG32\CA!gkbd0?AaүK/zP^7ox◭}k:λVgUO=W}u+uz_[OuutU꿧mwNVmj[!{i:v/I6ҭ_~WiZk_uZUt7On"n\_ivm$J鴪
+^aӤkU}5Е4I6[WAv0SµuF~XJ 7_tal%yA0BM[JM:+Il1ƷBbcm&+:gB.&ՃOKc]4%B4L.@aa< 0A$T
5i:j5jVLVI6KVMN$;_ePH0R ǴN[LB h aAa(0!t1 4
h0` aa 2)` @ @4AAiEDDDhDGPt]":0)1KX`4Wj0!5MrBBALP+1J-[D:Va4A""""""""""""T!#P0)S `DAbA8!Z9C":8@iqqDDDDDDFW^fT!XKI֖Kl&$
4,tigԬ""?l#$t[JC
2!d!w4GRP` Maah% Dxш#>A20H%hB"#.xAa& A+lE3@\&30DŢ93fGDs1vq3P!"莏Fe#D!B
2Fhѩh!
/E& 0S hA8"#b", aApB0C$DȜ\0[9vaa9&&nM6n=i6a
`ǃ0c Pn!ð0A4q1 mN:.i
#3i E"|L '$a\W!:3/uttkmMҠm; pviŦ?OkO_[I$[֞nm{
K_7;}:zuvZkuפ*] [tlG}tw=U;֩Rz龾ZO Ot~{L.zZ*KVևo8{W9,sK[XB=l-銿C_.W$!Ҥ"#]*-[0TuI.ӏ~g_0vnxDd1HuPAk%ϯ}]zMzniy-iQYǮqV_i/"Fo=t^$8O.LwI!Rۧ+nH5[YKip#|?]vנz_WImMJRJv$DC_>mUt-}&Uݷ_&_ߺz'l}]ukuhMoΫ%u/~~{ұzu^k_mi'=mK~+^WL¯a?/`/O]x_i&V]zM⫿b]:ۦK|}+IҴ{wZD`Q3têJޭMUdqi^ў[t 7֛K&kPN4A!
iN%nPQ30iCZRU[XIZL(Ia h 0@ؠA |SM1Q ЋjL'l0VWmVJ]c-RK(rVC@LSx(pD~X=q0(@@
P a(&A0$28dtGDtGAaSR3C9C2(r20r(pD~XcA;P-0aj,40!40 ADDCZmqDDDDDDDDDDDDDFHhD2(hAe:)#CeP8DtC2(rGDu(sPs;Uc8tTt:tWIwda|*nzW^I! @9C8Dt9qN?dEϢ:#莈`L&
ivLb22`_RC0POfq2
DuA8< 2s#;>f#:#|dtG3qn>80F